This is a very interesting thread.
I've been on MTX for a few years now. Started off with just a few pills of MTX and a high dose of Pred, but quickly escalated up to 8 pills per week (I was in a VERY bad way). I've not had a single hint of any side effect even if I take the pills on an empty stomach. It took a looooong time - several months - for it to start working and thus taper off the Pred.
Long story, but had to add Enbrel. Am still on the MTX but basically due to some diet and exercise I've lost weight to the point the rheumy slowly reduced the MTX dose and I'm down to 5 pills now.
I have some questions though to the people who take more than 8 pills: I've been inundated with information from my very knowledgable rheumy for the past several years and don't understand a lot of it and place quite a bit of trust in her (see the next paragraph below), and I could have sworn she said 8 pills was the maximum you could take in pill form. For those 9+ people - what mg are each of your individual pills?
And I agree with Journeyman's post in the middle of page 3, and think that most doctors are suspect in their motivations and their knowledge. But I think if you can find the right doctor then it is going to work. I really don't think there are many truly good doctors out there though. I trust my current doctor because she diagnosed me instantly and put me on medication that immediately started improving my horrible situation and has worked with me competently and caringly ever since. Although diagnosed around age 34 or so, I suspect that I've had arthritis since about age 15; that it was symptomatic enough to be correctly and fairly easily diagnosed starting around age 23 and yet up to this point and after my symptoms were frustratingly explained away and one docotor actually laughed at me; that the quacks who examined me between the ages of 24 and 33 were completely incompetent and one guy even possibly flirted with malpractice after barely glancing at my swollen knee and suggesting "exploratory surgery" when the x-rays looked fine (I grabbed my x-rays from this doctor's office and took them to the only doctor I've ever believed to have any intelligence - a podiatrist I saw decades before - it was the smartest thing I've ever done!); and I believe that he and my current rheumatologist that he referred me to are both saints!