I would be leery of the online academys...they are still like public/private schools (in fact most are considered to be private school) in that they have deadlines and take attendance etc... And (this is me personally, but many who homeschool their children agree), I wouldn't be looking to a school of any kind to teach socialization to my kids...that's one of the reasons I homeschool in the first place. There are several outside sources in which your children can learn how to communicate with others and have friends of varying ages ie; Girl Scouts (colleges love seeing girl scouts on transcript
s and they have some pretty amazing programs for girls of all ages), Church (if you attend), homeschool support groups (probably the single most important thing you can do as a homeschooler is to join one of these), these are just a few (there are many other resources out there), and you should be able to still participate in your local school's sports and music programs as well.
As for being organized, I'm pretty much the epitomy of what my mom has always called "an organized mess". LOL I try to be (and like to be) organized, but it's just not really who I am and, fortunately being organized is not a requirement to be a successful homeschooler. There is a huge amount of curricula out there to choose from and not everything will work for you and your child, so it might take some patience and perserverance in your hunt to find what works best for both of you, but honestly I wouldn't let anyone's comments (even mine lol) intimidate or discourage you from deciding on what is best for your child...besides God, only you know your child/children best and you alone are capable of making the right choices for them.
Again, I would look into what your state laws are for homeschooling (some states have far and away better laws than others) and see what resources the web site provides and use that as a starting place, continue to talk to others that you know who currently homeschool, and talk with your daughter about
what *she* wants to do... Good luck in your decision and keep us posted on what you decide!