p4h--mine's the same size as yours and the precuts work great...but, about a month ago I had a similar problem and even bought a supply of the next size up (which should have fit perfectly). You can imagine my surprise when I took out the first one, set it up and it was too BIG for me!!! (and I cannot send that box back...) I remeasured and I had gone back down. Now, mind you, I measured it for three changes before I ordered the new larger ones!!!
I put it off to maybe I gained a pound or two while I wasn't looking but I don't think it was enough to make that difference...now I am back to the smaller ones and don't have any problems!