He still has a prostate, so there is the possibility that there is some sort of infection or irritation in the remaining tissue. I've not heard of another surgery causing a rise.
But in general, a rise from 0.4 to 1.9 should not be ignored. If it were me, I would be standing in my uro's waiting room when they open tomorrow.
Welcome to HW. We hate to see you here, but fell free to ask questions as you need/want to.