Hi Gary,
I believe most everyone's experience & advice varies, this condition isn't really understood that well. I personally spoke or traveled to see all the 'Big Dogs" of Doctors around the nation. I bought every book & had every test. UCSF & Stanford experts told me I wasn't that bad & to ride it out. I had a MRI & every other kind of scan & they felt I was Okay & to continue all the NSAID's treatments & Colchicine. I couldn't do much of anything without unbarable pain 30-60 minutes later & then the pressure of the Pericardium would force my heart into Atrial Fibralation for 1-2 days until things settled down.
It is tough for Doctors to gauge without being able to clearly see inside. when they opened my up, the Surgeon said I had a thick white blanket of a Pericardium that was sufficating my heart. It was far worse than any of the Dr's thought.
One thing all Dr's agreed was that the Pericardium is not crucial to survival. One expert called it the "Trash Bag" the heart comes in.
The full pericardiectomy will be decided on when they open you up, they cut around the phrenic nerves & my surgeon told me he even got the back side off.
As far as being ripe, I was 51 years old & had lived with it for a little over 2 years & it was causing damage to other organs & of course the A-fib. I postponed surgery because I was reading way too much & also letting people scare me about the procedure. This internet is a double edged sword.
If you are healthy other than this, I would think it would be better to get it done although that is from my experience only.
I am in many support groups now since I was where you are at & you need to get a feel of what is going to take place.
Regarding the risk, I had 2 procedures done at once & I was worried most about the stripping until I actually met the Surgeon( Guadiani ) he insisted that for a good Surgeon that this is the easiest of all ( open heart) surgeries. I believe I wrote before that he called it " Heart Surgery 101"
The other thing about waiting is with time the Pericardium can calcify as portions of mine did. In ceratain areas they couldn't even get some of those portions off( small pieces)
You have to get the pressure off the Heart wall & therefore full removal is less likely to have any symptons in the future.
It was the best move I ever made, I have my full life back & now my biggest worry is my Golf swing which nobody can fix.
My email is attached & you can even email me with your phone # if you would like to talk.
It isn't a picnic but 8-10 weeks after the surgery you are back to a normal life.
Just find a Surgeon you have faith in, He will know what to do when he gets in there.
Boog