Hartshon said...
Hi Paul,
Thank you so much for your advice and tips - you have certainly given me a lot to consider! It is such a help to hear from someone else who has similar experiences as myself. Most people I meet who have AR seem to take the PPI and they are fine! Or they change their diet and it goes away. So its not really understood much...
It’s been quite a problem for me trying to sort out eating, drinking and sleeping – and I am still not there yet. Am struggling with getting the medication right and its difficult to know what is causing what (medication, what you eat and went you eat, sleeping)... Have had bad reactions to several PPIs and eventually managed to tolerate one - but feel it is not really doing much to improve my symptoms - in fact I feel worse! There is so much around about stopping taking them and controlling the AC naturally through diet... whats your thoughts on that?
My thoughts on that is quite controversial. Clearly, there are enough people who have benefited from using H2 blockers like Zantac and Proton Pump Inhibitors (PPIs) like Prilosec, Nexium, Dexilant, etc. that I would feel it irresponsible of me to say they don't work. Clearly, in some people they do. But most of these benefits have been studied on a short term basis (5 years and under).
There have been some new studies done on rats and other animals that are leading some people in the medical profession to do some more testing to see if acid reflux might be an autoimmune issue instead of a digestive issue. It's too early to tell if this is so and there is not enough data yet. And this is what's inherently frustrating for me because I know my current GI doctor means well, but she and my nutritionist have not agreed on many things and that's no surprise because my GI doctor isn't a nutrition expert and my nutritionist isn't a GI specialist.
So it's been a challenging road for me because basically, I'm using my body as an experiment right now, testing to see what is working for me and what isn't working for me.
Going back to your question, PPIs have some unwelcome side effects in some people and it's not clearly known what some of these long term effects might be.
I'm currently trying to heal my chronic gastritis and erosive esophagitis naturally. I've made it a point to not take any drugs for 90 days to see if my symptoms improve. Please note that I am NOT recommending anyone do this. I am doing this on my own because it worked before, so I have some history and data that this has worked for me before.
I am also starting a 14 day juice fast (using hemp protein powder for my amino acid source) and may extend it to 30 days or longer if the initial results are promising. I am doing this working on the theory that if I give my body the nutrients it needs (all organic of course) and also give it enough time to rest by juicing using a Vitamix blender (Nutribullet and Healthmaster will also work for this), that my esophagus and stomach lining will heal.
That remains to be seen, which is why I'm stating on a public forum that I am not recommending this course of action for you or anyone else because my situation is rather unique and I am under the care of a GI specialist and a nutritionist who are monitoring me on a weekly basis.
Hartshon said...
It has been hard to get used to a new way of eating - although I have always been careful with food, so am not adverse to not eating fatty foods. However, eating out has been quite a problem. I tend to go to places that offer simple food like fish or chicken with vegetables. Gone are the lovely thai or curries I used to adore :(
My home cooking has completely changed - where I used to cook spicy chili and lots of tomato based food. I had to re-educate myself on the art of cooking bland food! Like you - it is important to eat around 6pm to allow my food to digest (before I was eating very late 9-10). This has been quite a hard thing to change, and makes it very difficult socially, as most people eat around 8-9...
Initially I was reluctant to go away anywhere. Have recently managed a weeks holiday where I took a blow up bed that I put under the mattress which worked fairly well - but was a hassle pumping it up! I will certainly look at getting some adjustable bed risers for the next time I go away.
Its depressing, as this health problem has resulted in so many restrictions. I used to travel a lot in Europe and Far East staying in hotels for a few nights then moving on. Also loved camping – but that’s gone out the window for now!
I hear you on this point. My life style has completely changed (6 trips to the ER since 2011 will do that to a person). That is how difficult it was for me to change. It took a 6th trip to the ER and incredible amount of pain to finally motivate me enough to do whatever it took to make sure I didn't return for a 7th trip.
I wish I had taken my symptoms much more seriously the first time this happened.
But I loved going out to eat. I loved going out and drinking socially with my friends and my girlfriend. Wine-tasting was one of my favorite things to do and that has been put on hold indefinitely because I cannot even have one sip of wine right now. I loved my social life and I didn't want to give it up. I thought I could keep on drinking and eating what I wanted while the PPIs I was taking would "heal" me.
Little did I know at the time, that that isn't how our bodies work. You have to allow your body time to heal which means you have to stop eating and drinking things that keep it from doing so.
I have to remind myself every morning when I wake up, during the day, and when I go to bed that I have to put in these restrictions so that I can get better. And I have to stop thinking in terms of time. Should I go for 3 months, 6 months, two years? When?
No, I'm going to do this until all my symptoms are completely gone and then keep the restrictions for at least an extra 3 months. I don't want this pain to come back.
What also makes this incredibly frustrating is that the esophagus and stomach lining can take a long time to heal. And it's not clearly understood why one person can heal up in a few months while another person might take years. I suspect diet and other factors to be part of the variables, but who really knows.
I understand about traveling. I'm big on travel, hiking, and biking. I can no longer hike or bike, and my traveling has been very limited. Right now it seems as though I'm living to go to work and then the rest of my time is spent on getting better, watching a lot of Netflix, reading books, and writing my short stories.
Oh, and making a lot of organic bone broth. =)
Hartshon said...
The foods you list are very similar to my diet. Sushi is a good idea. I was interested to see that you eat organic baby food – hadn’t thought of that before! What do you drink? Yes – it is a real challenge sticking to a simple diet – especially when important social event occur. I really don't like making a fuss and explaining my health issue...
Yes, I ate organic baby food for the first two weeks after my last trip to the emergency room. I was in too much pain to eat solid foods. I still eat organic baby food as a snack though during the day. When I see them on sale I buy them in bulk. If you're so inclined just perform a Google search for "baby food recipes" and you'll find plenty of them! You can also make your own baby food.
I'm limiting my sushi intake to twice a week at the moment because I don't want to expose myself to too much Mercury. Wild Caught Salmon is one of my favorite things to cook too.
As far as what I drink I keep it really simple:
* filtered water (I never drink tap water, it's not good for you)
* Alkaline water (I'm experimenting with this, initial results are encouraging)
* Home made ginger tea
* Organic chamomile tea
* Coconut Water (this can cause GERD in some people, so be careful with this one)
* Home made juices (I don't buy juices from the store because they generally add things like high fructose corn syrup). I prefer carrot juice, celery juice, apple juice, and vegetable / fruit smoothies
Hartshon said...
I have always watched my diet and have never been overweight. However, I have also lost quite a lot of weight since having this problem and am worried I am getting too thin. Just wondered how you make sure you get calories?
I've lost a lot of weight (40 pounds since the New Year), but I view it as a good thing. First of all, I needed to lose those 40 pounds because I was overweight. Secondly, my focus is on getting better and not necessarily maintaining my weight at this time, though I do want to stress it is important to make sure you are getting the nutrition your body needs.
It's essential to get the protein you need (among other things) in order to maintain a healthy weight. But if you have severe GERD, gastritis, or esophagitis, then you're NOT healthy at the moment and it's time to get your body back in balance. So many people do lose weight because they cannot keep food down, it's too painful to eat too much, and many other reasons.
If people follow the introductory diet from Dr. Koufman's book they ARE going to lose weight, because you'll be eating a lot more healthy foods such as vegetables. "Rice should be a staple" the book states, but it should also be noted that you shouldn't go crazy on eating too much rice, especially if you're diabetic.
Right now I get my calories by eating lot of vegetables, chicken vegetable soup using home made bone broth, some steamed white rice (brown rice is better for you but I find it very hard to digest so I am staying away from it for about 90 days), baked potato (I don't eat the skin), certain fruits (bananas and peeled red apples are my favorites though YMMV), smoothies (please note I will add protein powder to my smoothies about 3x per week), fish, and other lean meats (I eat very little red meat because it's tough for me to digest).
Hartshon said...
Eating early has helped me – but I have not got used to eating more frequent smaller meals. However (from my PH test) I suffer from nocturnal reflux mainly, and even when I eat early I still wake up in the early morning from reflux occurring. It seems strange, as I would think there is nothing in my stomach then… Interesting tip about eating apples before going to bed and chewing gum – will try that.
Not sure about bile reflux – how do you know you may have this?
My last endoscopy showed that my gastritis was caused by bile reflux. So it was imperative that I stay away from fatty and fried foods.
Since you are getting a lot more reflux while you sleep you may want to try this one for size because it helped me:
* about an hour before you go to bed eat 2 to 4 slices of a peeled organic red apple. This has been known to alleviate GERD symptoms in some people. It's not understood yet why. Some think it has to do with the enzymes it has, other think it helps keep the stomach more alkaline.........well, whatever the reason I have found this works for me. You may want to give it a try.
Hartshon said...
Will check out Dr Twogood online regarding chronic pain - as my back pain has become much more constant and is waking me up during the night and generally making my life miserable (lack of sleep and depression).
Just wondered if your pain was controlled much by any medication then? PPI or Evril?
You seem to have an open-minded consultant. I have been seeing a well renowned GI consultant in Harley Street in London, who seems to think diet has little impact! He told me not to spend too much money on fancy diets or naturapath doctors!
Interesting you say meditation helps. I have been doing Thai Chi, which has helped. Its taken a while to get used to as I have always been the one pounding in the gym – so doing something very slow has been very strange. Like you say moderate exercise is good. Have also looked at Mindfulness – but have not really been practicing it long enough. Like you say – the more you do it the better you get at it.
Thank you so much for the list of tips.
I wish you all the best for a speedy recovery...
I have not taken any medications for my pain as I have chosen to grin and bear it for about 90 days to see if a natural diet will help. It's been about a month now and my symptoms have gotten slightly better, which I find encouraging.
Though Dr. Twogood specializes in chronic pain, I found his material to have a lot of crossover into my GERD symptoms. To me it makes logical sense that if chocolate, dairy, MSG, aspartame, certain medications, etc. can cause inflammation in our bodies, then wouldn't then also cause digestive problems? According to Dr. Twogood the answer is a resounding yes.
So I have chosen to follow his elimination diet of 90 days which is why I'm staying away from all of the foods he lists. It is also the reason I've chosen to not eat out at my favorite restaurants anymore because even places that say they don't use MSG, might still unknowingly use MSG in any sauces they use.
Unfortunately, there are many GI doctors like yours who seem to think that "diet" has "little impact" on your GERD symptoms. Just bear in mind that most GI doctors who have been trained in Western medicine are NOT nutritionists and have very limited studies on nutrition. So statements like that are usually made out of ignorance, not necessarily ego.
Also there are well over 10,000 new chemicals and additives in our foods that didn't exist 30 years ago. No GI doctor in the world can lay claim to knowing if all of these 10,000 chemicals are good for you and what impact they might have on your GERD.
I had to go through 2 GI doctors before I found my 3rd one, and as much as I like her, she does have her limitations, which is why I sought a nutritionist that had a history of success with dealing with GERD symptoms. I have found having both of them as part of my "health team" invaluable.
This thing I am certain of: diet has a MAJOR impact on GERD. Your GI doctor might not think so, but there is far more data out there today that proves your doctor wrong. Ask your GI doctor what they think of MSG and it's impact to GERD?
I will give your doctor some benefit of the doubt in that he/she wants you to stay away from "fancy diets" that might not work. In that regard he/she might be trying to protect you. But I can assure you, that eating a healthy, organic diet is far superior than eating processed foods. I would think even your own GI doctor would agree with that.
I'm happy that you're looking into Thai Chi, as I think that would be a great form of exercise. It's very important to do some body movement during the day.
Yes, meditation has been extremely helpful to me. It's something that is not easy to measure, but if nothing else, it helps me stay relaxed and helps me stay in the moment. It has also done wonders for alleviating my anxiety.
Good luck to you.