Can you please share your source for this?
mpost said...
"...if you are obese ketosis can kill you because your liver will be overwhelmed by liquified fat and die."
I have to wonder about
your source. My husband is obese and has repeatedly lost weight with various low-carb diets, but always gets stuck about
70 lb overweight and always gains it back in a few years. He has recently lost 61 lb on a ketogenic diet and plans to lose ~70 more. He has researched it a lot more than I have and may have counter info. I know that Johns Hopkins had these nutritionally deficient keto shakes they used to put kids on, virtually every negative health detriment ever published about
ketogenic diets is actually based on sick kids who lived on these shakes (and often died on these shakes). I will pass this along to him and see what he says. What you said is either potentially life-saving, or bad info that you have shared in good faith, not knowing enough about
ketosis either way to know if your source is reliable (whether it is really about
a healthy ketogenic diet, or is really about
those awful Johns Hopkins shakes that gave everyone nutritional deficiencies).
Insofar as what you said:
mpost said...
"Glucose is needed by your cells."
They can also alternatively run on ketones, the brain does especially well on ketones. The muscles do need glycogen, but your liver can produce that, even on a ketogenic diet. There is a special form of the ketogenic diet for athletes who perform better than when they were carb loading instead (such as marathon runners and power lifters). Ketosis allows you to break down your own fat and fuel your body with it, which is what these athletes do, and they don't risk their lives (by crashing when they run out of glycogen mid-marathon), like carb loaders do. I can provide sources if needed.
If your source is right, I don't want my husband risking his life to lose weight. I was at the top of Obesity I and now I'm only Overweight and approaching a healthy weight. I already lost all my excess subcutaneous fat and only have some extra belly fat to lose (visceral fat, the brown fat that is harder to lose than the subcutaneous white fat). He now weighs ~ what I weighed when I started the diet in May. He has never been much below the Obesity I/II line in his life, whereas I've been everywhere from a healthy weight to the top of Obesity I. He's hoping this is finally what does it for him.
mpost said...
"Unless you have uncontrolled epileptic seisures you should have no reason to put yourself into ketosis."
Actually, there are many, many medical conditions helped by ketosis, from both types I and II diabetes to Alzheimer's to heart problems to rheumatoid arthritis. My friend whose kid has severe cystic fibrosis wants to start him on a ketogenic diet (he has other health issues and she has to wait to start it, but it looks promising for him).
So, I really want to familiarize myself with your source. One of us has been seriously mislead! If it's me, then more than one life could be saved by your reply. If it's you, then more people here may be helped by a ketogenic diet.
I do want to mention one more thing: a lot of people have temporary flu-like symptoms when adapting to a keto diet. Gradually adopting a keto diet can help. People familiar with ketogenic diets call this, "keto flu." I do wonder if some Lymies might mistake it for herxing. I assume that anyone who has been treating it for a long time can tell one from the other, but I should be sure to let people know this, if I'n suggesting a ketogenic diet might help.
P.S. Sorry to everyone if I did the quote thing wrong!