I contacted a friend of mine (Navy Vet) who is quite knowledgable on this subject, plus he is one of the major contributors to our Wichita Chapter of UsTOO (
http://www.ustoowichita.org/ and he advised the following. I hope it will shed some light..........
Of the “Blue Waters” ships that HAVE BEEN approved, there is not one ammunition ship (AE) on the list, and the ship in the dispute is USS Mount Katmai (AE-16). Considering that they were ammunition ships, they likely were not permitted to actually enter the “Blue Waters” off Vietnam and more likely were kept quite distant. Though the Commander in the court dispute received Vietnam medals, so did just about anyone that participated in the general area of that conflict, including support at sea of those combatant ships, boats, and landing craft that did move close into the area that has been accepted now as being in the so-called “Blue Waters.” The latest updates to a list of U.S. Navy and Coast Guard (USCG) vessels exposed to Agent Orange during the Vietnam Era has come out and includes many ships that were much closer in off Vietnam as well as combatants in inland waters. “The updated list, maintained by the Department of Veterans' Affairs (VA), is available at www.fra.org/agentorange and is of particular interest to those former service members experiencing health problems related to herbicide exposure. If service aboard one of the listed vessels can be confirmed, it may help expedite claims for VA health and disability benefits. Veterans should understand that the list is not complete and presumption of exposure will not be denied solely because a veteran's ship is not on it.”