Posted 11/14/2020 1:41 AM (GMT 0)
I don't understand why a new scan wouldn't be valued, at least for a point of reference.
My Mayo Clinic scans are valued by my local oncologist, and scans my local oncologist request that I undergo, are referenced, shared, and valued by Mayo Clinic.
That's just my personal experience, which I feel is how it should be --- coordinated care.
If THEY don't really feel Provenge has much potential to help, as they seemed to indicate for your dad's case, and your dad's initial PSA was 700, why would Provenge rate as their frontline treatment idea, when they seemed so uncertain that it would even help?
They don't seem very hopeful that PROVENGE will make much of a difference for your dad. Why is that their "Plan A" for your father?
That's just my initial concern.
By contrast, when I started Zytiga, my oncologist ordered a PSA within about 3 weeks, to see if it was making a difference. When I started chemotherapy, PSA was tested before each infusion, to assess efficacy of previous treatments.
My reason for sharing this is that these new treatments were monitored closely --- and efficacy of the treatment was constantly monitored.
I only state this as a something to reflect upon, as a comrade --- since you are seeking thoughts and reflections.
Their Step #2 in the treatment sequence is to look for a clinical trial, anyway --- and your local oncologist is offering that right NOW, with a combination of TWO known cancer fighting agents. Is that worth a second look?
Just some reflective thoughts -- offered out of brotherly concern.
You seem uncertain, perhaps, and so I offer these as discussion points for you and your father.
Humble thoughts -- no medical expertise implied or intended, on my part, whatsoever.
You seem to be "caught" between two very differing medical approaches being offered to you. I wish they had a shared & cohesive "vision" for the next-step treatments ...
I would have felt the new scans your father took this week should have at least warranted their interest, before formulating the treatment plan.
Why else did your dad go through time-consuming and costly scans this week, right before the consultation?
I always discuss the need and relevance of every scan with my doctors, before agreeing to each follow-up scan.
You asked for honest thoughts, and these reflections were mine, after reading your post.
I have followed your posts all along, and want the very best for your father's case.
My very best,
CYCLONE --- # Iowa State University