Posted 6/4/2023 11:19 PM (GMT 0)
Mattam -- Thanks for the heads-up on the CO2. A new form of gassy discomfort. I'm glad you've made it through your PCa journey thus far and are sticking around to guide newbies like myself.
I hear you on the sales-pitch vibe but it's just me, aiming to convince myself with my own synopsis.
After talking to two ROs I really was inclined towards the RT approach, particularly proton beam b/c of the purported accuracy. But in studying the RT variants, I kept seeing this word "ablation." In surgery this equates to "removal." In RT / Cryo / HIFU it simply means "destruction of tissues."
I'm a visual person and I couldn't escape the image of baking my prostate into a leathery hacky-sack and leaving it in there.
Of the 3 surgeons I met with, one turned me off b/c he was really pitching HIFU (he's involved in a clinical study); the second was very sharp & talented but unacceptably young, who thankfully was gracious & supportive about referring me to surgeon #3, his senior colleague, the esteemed Igor Frank MD.
In the course of my consult with Dr. Frank I asked about his experience with salvage surgery after RT, he said that it is far more difficult than primary treatment because you're basically "working with a ball of scar tissue."
That hacky-sack again...
Another factor for me is my "other cancer." In 2010 I had a fast-growing oropharyngeal tumor under the base of my tongue, excised @ Mayo by another esteemed surgeon who had been innovating the use of Da Vinci systems for trans-oral surgeries, getting down deep in the gullet. He got negative margins despite my tumor's proximity to my hyoid bone, and with my negative neck dissection he was confident that I did not need any adjuvant treatment.
Five years later, just as I was declared "clear", a good friend of mine had a very similar diagnosis but was a bit more advanced. After his excision he had to endure a grueling adjuvant RT course and spent many months recovering from the SEs. He's good now, but he's got permanent damage, more from the RT than the excision.
I was lucky with my circumstances & with landing that particular ENT surgeon. I wound up with modest nerve damage, some temporary, some permanent (crooked smile.) So I guess I'm predisposed to trust surgeons -- in particular if I have a skilled surgeon.
My wife has been my rock through everything, and she did quite a bit of her own additional research as I considered my PCa treatment options. Honestly I probably could have swung the other way & gone with Proton Beam / Hacky-Sack if that's what she believed was best, but she was laser-focused on the optimal oncological outcome, and for her surgery won by a nose. We both like the immediate situational awareness that comes with surgery, and we decided the more palatable order of events if I needed salvage treatment would be surgery first, RT later.
I'm blessed to have all these various extraordinary treatment options available to me. Another comment from Dr. Frank echoed sentiments I've seen here on HW: he noted I'm right smack in the diagnostic zone where I have *all* the options, which can make the decision harder.
It helps that Dr Frank has a warm yet studious manner which gave my wife & I a solid level of confidence. So I'm putting myself, literally, in his hands...
nels