InTheShop said...
There was a time I was afraid.
Of dying of a sudden heart attack.
Now I fear of
the long slow
wasting that is
cancer.
------
Better poetry after I've had my afternoon tea.
Andrew
You've got that right, Bro, IMO! The latter is much more worthy of dread.
Pratoman said...
This is what I'm looking for the answer to, and I have a feeling the answer is unknowable.
Bro Prato, I suspect your feeling is right on. As I have continued to read the pro-no meat book which directly contradicts all of those studies I have linked to, and directly contradicts (at least to the degree that I can know limited to known results) my own personal experience, I feel more and more that we can not know. I think we could know, but- just like with anything that does not make huge money for someone- the unequivocal studies n a large scale will never be done. I mean really, why is any of this still debatable, why don't we KNOW? Except, we can-
with limitations- know, by trying whatever and seeing how it goes, hopefully not killing us first. By limitations, I mean: most of us can not have our chest cut
open or have imaging done to see if our blockages have gotten better or worse due to our interventions.
We can only go by the various indirect indicators, plus consider how we feel.
Correct me if I am wrong, but is it not
almost written in stone that it is a good thing for heart health to lower hip to waist ratio, lower BP, lower blood insulin, reduce diabetes/pre-diabetes/metabolic syndrome, lower triglycerides and raise HDL? Is there anyone out there who claims that these are not laudable goals if we desire heart health? I have not seen anyone saying: "you need to lower your HDL and raise your TGLs and waist size", but you never know, I might have missed them.
The pro vegan book I am reading is claiming that a vegan way of eating can improve all of those parameters and actually reverse much disease. (Does dramatically improving all of those parameters reverse heart and other diseases, or is it something else that gets reversed and then leads to an improvement in those tests? I don't know, I have seen no studies. )
Here is one thing I feel I do know, based on my personal experience, my friends exp., and at least when it comes to TGLs(and maybe HDL and weight?) your experience, and many studies: a low carb diet, even if high fat and more than reasonable calories, can do every one of those things in spades. For example, lowering my TGLs from somewhere over 200 to 39, raising my HDL from about
30 to 50, systolic BP from 140 to <110, etc etc. (see next post)