yep, tried many differnet brands - first on my two children, but also for myself. The Buttpaste is a really good one - it has a higher concentration of zinc than other brands which helps build a barrier from more moisture hitting the area. The absolute best one though, is called Triple Paste. It costs much more than all the others, but is worth it if the area is really raw and blistered. It has a much higher amount of zinc plus other ingredients than all the other brands. Its defintely is worth it if the area is bad off. The other cheaper brands work well for just a little irritation.