I was just thinking about
this. Here's my thoughts. For me I did awesome on Probiotics (High Dose) for a very long time (3 months) then I flared overnight in a big way. Edit: I was in remission when I really started adding them in high does
Then, I didn't take them while I was on Pred and Immuran and recovered well'ish. SO I added them back in now and then. I started the AA therapy and did great - till I added probiotics - and wham - massive gas, and D. Stopped them, improved, tried again - same thing. Stayed away for a while and then over the last month or so started drinking Kefir Milk on a daily basis. This brought the return of mucus. Then I did the sauerkraut, kefir milk and yogurt meal and whamo - Massive pain and problems - huge flare and a call to the GI for Pred.
I've stayed away and am seeing great improvement.
SO here's my thought:
Even though probiotics are perhaps beneficial from an inflammatory perspective and all that good stuff we've read- they are NOT commensal to the colon. And therefore, if there's a breakdown in the mucus barrier they probably generate quite the immune reaction if they come into contact with the epithelial cells (They are foreign after all). More so, in very large quantities the reaction could be quite intense. Also the shape of these probiotic bacteria may make it easy for them to get to the epithelial cells as we learned from your other paper.
So I think in general this really points again to the breakdown of the mucus barrier at the root as you suggest. And depending on how bad and how much surface area is experiencing this breakdown, every body is going to react somewhat different.
Once the barrier is repaired however they probably do have a positive effect on low grade inflammation via adjusting the dysiosis etc, but until that point perhaps they are a no-no for some.
Post Edited (Canada Mark) : 9/19/2013 1:28:42 PM (GMT-6)