MariaMaria said...
...
At the risk of sounding naive, I don't think it's right to declare that UC is "chronic" and can never be cured. There have been many people in FMT research studies and on this forum who have seemingly cured their diseases through FMT. A friend of mine did FMT with his mother as a donor for severe crohns colitis and has been symptom free, medication free and on so special diet for nearly 10 years. His mother Sky Curtis wrote the book "A Gut Reaction". Her stance, which I agree with, is that the body does not simply attack itself for no reason. In order for the body to go into an autoimmune response, it has to be responding to something. It's figuring out what that "something" is that leads us to answers.
Yes. This is incredibly naive, and arrogant. Autoimmune is well document ina number of syndromes. In some cases the antigens identified are clearly to self/own tissue. The immune system "learns" what is to be attacked, and with autoimmune it has learned that some host tissue or commensal microbes are to be attacked. These are facts, you cannot dismiss them.
It is possible not all cases of diagnosed UC is true autoimmune. It is also possible that some diagnosed cases are not actually UC, but undetected infection, or severe dysibosis of the gut microbe ecology.
I thin FMT works best for conditions misdiagnosed as UC. I have recommended it to folks that have tried everything else. But in controled studies, where the UC diagnosis is confirmed, and some get FMT which some get placebo - there has been no statistically significant evidence. Maybe a few more in the real FMT group than the placebo FMT group showed improvement - but not more than could have occurred by chance.
Saying things like "the body just does not attack itself for no reason" is just ignorant and incredibly disrespectful of science. It does, it has, its complicated - and you obviously don't comprehend.
I am glad this probiotic therapy seems to be helping you symptoms, and hope it is also helping you at the histological level. I hope you can reduce or even switch out meds for some anti-inflammatory foods or other supplement.
I am sad you are so dismissive of science.